
Last night there was a vicious battle on the networks. Years from now competition scholars will look back at the past four-hundred years of human achievement and several key moments in our competitive evolution will stand out: Frazier/Ali, The Miracle on Ice, the 2004 ALCS, and last night’s American Idol/Dancing with the Stars showdown.
Yes, Idol and Stars went head to head like two rabid cougars fighting over an elk carcass. It was bloody, but the gore wasn’t visible on television, instead it could be found in the network board rooms.
First of all, no one is going to say that Dancing with the Stars is even remotely as culturally significant as Idol, though it’s hard to deny it isn’t popular. Viewers are tuning in. Lots of them. What’s curious is Idol seemed to have taken this added excitement as a personal threat (though its numbers haven’t wavered the slightest from its nearby competition), and went on the offense.
American Idol ran one hour and seven minutes last night — seven minutes. That made Idol run right over the beginning of the Dancing With the Stars results show (which was slated to begin at 9:00pm EDT). That takes some onions. That’s like the biggest bully on the playground finding the next biggest kid and kicking the sh!t of him in front of his friends as a warning to anyone who might have had ideas of their own glory.
The story doesn’t end there. When I pulled up Dancing on my DVR a lower-third flashed on the screen. It read: Live results show starts in FOUR minutes. Touché, ABC. Touché.
By the time the titles ran on ABC, the clock read 9:08pm. One full minute after American Idol had ended.
Advantage: ABC.
As for the show itself, which I had never watched before, it might have been the most padded hour of television I’d ever seen, and by the time the first couple was voted off I realized I had absolutely no idea who these people were. Paulina… Alec… which one was the celebrity?
Still, the show has enough eye-candy for me to understand whatever ratings it generates.
Idol was Idol. Go… um… Jordin Sparks(?) — best name ever, btw.