
This past weekend my half-roommate and I were watching some old episodes of Freaks and Geeks and Undeclared. Those two shows succeeded for many reasons. Like The Office and Arrested Development a lot of the praise should be placed squarely at the feet of the cast. Judd Apatow may not have ever figured out how to create a television show that wouldn’t get cancelled, but he has developed a keen eye for actors and casting. Along with Seth Rogen, one of his greatest finds was Jason Segel, who played Nick on Freaks and Geeks, Eric on Undeclared and is currently seen as Marshall in the exceptionally charming (and often downright hilarious) How I Met Your Mother.
While watching last night’s HIMYM something struck me about Segel and his presence on the show: it’s solidly underwhelming. This isn’t to say that he isn’t great on it. He plays the character as good as anyone would, but that’s just it: anyone could play that character. Well perhaps not anyone. Tom Sizemore, for example, would be horrible in that role. Marshall needs to only be adorable and lovable. Segel can pull this off in spades, but it hardly utilizes his most significant asset: his bizarre and sometimes freakish intensity.
What’s funny is that his three most significant roles have all been essentially the role of “Boyfriend.” The difference with his Marshall character is he’s madly in love and that love is being reciprocated. In Freaks… Nick loved Lindsay more than Lindsay loved (or even liked) him. In Undeclared Eric loved Lizzie to the point of obsession all while she was in the process of dumping him. Jason Segel needs that edge. He can deliver the creepiest and most hilariously penetrating stare you’ve ever seen. It’s a silent and completely internal performance. Which is all the more fascinating when paired against these over-the-top moments of compulsive energy (like Nick singing “Lady” to Lindsay in his parent’s basement or Eric manically assembling valentines at a copy shop for Lizzie).
How I Met Your Mother has given Segel some room to show Marshall’s crazier, more intense, side (last week’s episode featured a great sequence where he blackmailed a seven-year-old out of his pudding cup). Unfortunately, more often than not he’s being relegated to the silly — not a terrible fate, but in a cast as great as theirs its a shame he can’t let loose more often.